Fat Steve's Blatherings

Thursday, September 01, 2005

Thoughts on the Gulf Coast

Summary:

      Will says the New Orleans disaster couldn't have been planned for.  He's 90% right.

At Length:

      Over at Free Will, there's a long post I almost agree with.  Basically, it says 'Shut up about "Why isn't any body doing anything, and why wasn't there a plan for this?", because the answer is, this isn't the kind of thing you can plan for.  When something like this happens, you're screwed.'

      My disagreement, such as it is, is with the difference between 'could' and 'would.'  At one point, Will asks what can be done about looters?  Shoot them?  Why yes, that would work nicely.  But the mayor, and perhaps the governor, can't bring themselves to make the decision.

      The same is true for some of the other things he mentions.  The levees weren't strong enough for a category 5 storm, only a 3?  They could have been made stronger decades ago.  There could have been better evacuation planning, but nobody wanted to face the nightmare, or do things that might turn out to be unnecessary.

      This is all very human.  'If we do nothing, maybe the problem will go away on its own.'  A few years ago, I was without power for a week.  I swore I'd buy an emergency generator as soon as possible.  Real Soon Now . . .

      And if the politicians had tried to do something, much of the public wouldn't have supported them, some would even have opposed them.  So, in terms of what was politically possible before the storm, yes, Will's mostly right.  But if we have the gumption, we can do better than this.  And we should.

      Hat tip: Instapundit.

Update: Some thoughts on disaster preparedness here, from Glenn Reynolds.

THE HOUSE OF SAUD MUST BE DESTROYED — AND WILL BE!

5 Comments:

  • You bring up some amazing points about the necessity of consistency in blogging. My web site used to be a very successful blog until I tried to make it great. I brought in a grip of friends, tried using intellectual comedy, and as a result alienated most of our audience.

    Ted
    homeschool science

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 5:28 PM  

  • I hope they rebuild and when they do they should rebuild the levee the correct way.

    By Blogger Me, at 5:30 PM  

  • Katrina Reignites Global Warming Debate
    Hurricane Katrina's fury has reignited the scientific debate over whether global warming might be making hurricanes more ferocious.
    Hey, you have a great blog here! I'm definitely going to bookmark you!

    I have a make money site. It pretty much covers make money related stuff.

    Come and check it out if you get time :-)

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 5:33 PM  

  • JBoss CEO Marc Fleury comments on 'commercial open source'
    Per your article , with top-down, VC-created open source companies, I think the issue people are still waiting to see play out is whether or not money and the use of open source as a distribution and marketing ...


    I like the way you have layed out your blog! I am currently working on one
    myself when I find time from creating new sites.

    If you would be intested in checking out my site on smooth treadmill
    I would appreciate any comments. It basically covers smooth treadmill related stuff.

    If you have time check it out :-)

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 5:39 PM  

  • Army Cracks Down on Military Bloggers
    Army Chief of Staff Gen. Peter Schoomaker circulated a memo to all Army personnel last week saying that "we must do a better job" at operational security -- "OPSEC" in military parlance.
    Regards
    Duncan
    Helping you buy and sell your house at
    faster

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 5:43 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home